London, October 17, 2025
British officials are working to overturn a decision that bars supporters of Maccabi Tel Aviv from attending their team’s Europa League away match at Aston Villa on November 6, citing public safety concerns. The ban, ordered by the Safety Advisory Group on advice from West Midlands Police, has drawn sharp criticism from political leaders, sports authorities, and Jewish advocacy groups.
West Midlands Police had classified the fixture at Villa Park as “high risk,” citing past incidents including violent clashes and hate crimes when Maccabi fans played at Ajax in Amsterdam during the 2024 Europa League. Concerns included protests and threats outside the stadium, and uncertainty over the ability to hold effective security measures.
Prime Minister Keir Starmer called the decision “the wrong decision,” and emphasized that football fans of all backgrounds should be able to enjoy matches safely. Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy is among those pushing for a review of the ban, saying ministers are exploring alternative security measures that could allow fans to attend.
Simon Foster, the elected Police and Crime Commissioner for the West Midlands, has formally requested an immediate review of the decision. He asked to examine the reports, intelligence assessments, and legal justifications underlying the ban, and whether the measure is appropriate, necessary, and proportionate.
Sports authorities, including UEFA, have urged local officials to seek a path that balances safety with the rights of visiting supporters. Jewish leadership groups have criticized the ban as discriminatory, warning it could contribute to perceptions of unfair treatment and raise concerns about antisemitism.
The club, Aston Villa, has stated that the decision was made by the Safety Advisory Group and is based on advice from police. They noted that discussions are ongoing with Maccabi Tel Aviv and relevant authorities to assess whether measures can be put in place to allow fans to attend without compromising public safety.
As pressure mounts, attention is focused on whether legal or procedural alternatives—such as enhanced policing, segregated entry arrangements, or special safety zones—can address the concerns raised, while respecting fan rights.
This issue has reignited broader debates over how sports fixtures involving international and politically sensitive clubs are secured in the UK, particularly amid heightened concerns over antisemitism and protester safety.
